Negligence Claims -Surveyors Take Heed

Expert Witness

by Mark O’Hara, Bsc MRICS

Prior to 2012 surveyors avoided liability by claiming ignorance of Japanese knotweed or the damage that it can cause. This all changed when in 2012 the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors published guidance on ‘Japanese knotweed and residential property’.

How do you recognise a Japanese knotweed? The plant forms dense stands of tall canes up to 3m (10 feet) during summer, which die back in autumn. It is an invasive perennial weed that is thought to have been introduced to Britain in the late 19th Century as an ornamental plant. During spring, the plant produces rapidly growing light red shoots resembling bamboo, and can grow to a height of 2-3m, with the rhizome (root system) spreading outwards under the surface for up to 7m from stems visible above ground.

Japanese knotweed is a major problem to property, due to its ability to damage structures and spread rapidly from small fragments. The Environment Agency describes as “indisputably the UK’s most aggressive, destructive and invasive plant”.

The risk to the surveyor report is the absence of plants in the winter when they die back and are not obviously apparent. Individual plants can cover large areas of land, joined up below ground by an extensive rhizome network.

How Japanese knotweed spreads
In Britain Japanese knotweed spreads from when small pieces of the plant or rhizomes (underground root-like stems) are broken off. One piece of rhizome or plant the size of a fingernail can produce a new plant.

Pieces of plant or rhizome can easily be transported to a new location without awareness by:
1. water – if the plant is growing close to a river or stream
2. moving soil which contains plant pieces
3. dumping such as fly-tipping the removed stems

Not only is the surveyor required to inspect the property but must also consider the adjoining land. Knotweed does not recognise boundaries and needs to be considered carefully.

The Cost to the homeowner
Regrettably, the slightest trace of Japanese knotweed on the property – even on nearby on the street – is a reason to be refused a mortgage

• Treatment costs.
The removal, eradication and disposal of the weed may be expensive but given that the presence of it can impede the sale of your property and/or affect the value, a least-risk approach would be to have it removed by licensed contractors and properly disposed of.

• Refused lending if the mortgage company suspects there is the presence of the weed; and

• Potential loss of sale if the weed is found during the buyer’s survey

Legal obligations
Landowners are under a statutory duty to take steps to control and eradicate Japanese knotweed. All parts of the plant and any soil contaminated with it are
classified as controlled waste and must be removed and disposed of by a licensed waste control operator. If you have invasive plants on land that you own or occupy, you must comply with specific legal responsibilities, including:
• spraying invasive plants with herbicide
• cutting and burning invasive plants
• burying invasive plant material on site
• disposing of invasive plants and contaminated soil off site

Japanese knotweed is not on the increase but awareness of this plant is. For this reason and particularly in the coming months surveyors must be diligent.

Mark O’Hara, Bsc MRICS

The Environment Agency’s Knotweed Code of Practice provides guidance for managing Japanese knotweed and includes information on knotweed identification and waste disposal.
Available at